Journal Policy 1
1. Editorial Office
- Conducts initial administrative screening to ensure completeness of submission files (Authors’ Undertaking and Contribution Statement, ethics approval or client consent, reporting checklist, and a separate title page with an anonymized manuscript).
- Returns incomplete submissions to authors for correction before further processing.
2. Editor
The Editor of AJCBT is Prof. Dr. Farooq Naeem, founder of the Pakistan Association of Cognitive Therapy (PACT). The Editor leads the journal and:
- Has final authority for all editorial decisions, including acceptance or rejection.
- Ensures editorial independence, integrity, and adherence to journal policies.
- Oversees the resolution of ethical issues and complaints, as per COPE flowcharts.
3. Handling Editor
Each manuscript is handled by the Editor or by an Editorial Board member designated by the Editor. The Handling Editor:
- Performs technical and content triage to assess scope, originality, and scientific merit.
- Makes initial editorial decisions (reject, return for revision, or send for external review).
- Selects and invites appropriate peer reviewers.
- Evaluates reviewer feedback and makes recommendations to the Editor for acceptance, revision, or rejection.
- Ensures that all editorial actions comply with COPE guidelines and AJCBT policies.
4. Editorial Board Members
- Serve as subject experts for triage or peer review.
- Advise the Editor on policy, scope, and publication standards.
- May act as Handling Editors, and may participate in adjudicating conflicting reviewer opinions or appeals.
5. Chief Advisor
The Chief Advisor, Prof. Dr. Akhtar Sherin, advises the Editor on the journal’s strategy, editorial policies, and publication ethics, and may be consulted on appeals, complaints, and matters of research integrity.
6. Advisory Board
The Advisory Board comprises senior academics and clinicians in psychiatry, clinical psychology, and CBT from Pakistan and abroad. Members advise on the journal’s scope, direction, and standards, help promote the journal and identify reviewers, and may be invited to review manuscripts within their expertise. The Advisory Board is not involved in decisions on individual manuscripts unless invited to review.
7. Managing Editor
The Managing Editor, Aqsa Yaqoob, functions as the operational lead of the journal’s editorial process. The Managing Editor ensures smooth manuscript flow from submission to publication, maintains communication with authors, reviewers, and editors, and upholds adherence to journal policies, timelines, and ethical standards. While the Editor has final authority on editorial decisions, the Managing Editor ensures their efficient execution.
8. Copyeditor / Production Team
- Responsible for formatting, language, APA 7 style, and technical consistency after acceptance.
- Prepares final galley proofs and coordinates author approval before publication.
9. Leadership and Selection of the Editorial Team
AJCBT was established by PACT, and is led by its founder, Prof. Dr. Farooq Naeem, as Editor. Other members of the editorial team — including Editorial Board and Advisory Board members — are selected by the Editor from among qualified academics, clinicians, and high-performing peer reviewers. Selection emphasizes academic merit, expertise in CBT and related fields, editorial experience, research output, and commitment to publication ethics. AJCBT aims to ensure geographic, institutional, and disciplinary diversity in its editorial team — across clinical psychology, psychiatry, and allied mental health disciplines, and across Pakistan and the international CBT community.
10. Submission, Screening, and Triage
Every newly submitted manuscript undergoes an initial screening by the Editorial Office, under the supervision of the Managing Editor, to verify that all required files are complete and that the submission meets the journal’s requirements. This includes checking:
- The Authors’ Undertaking and Contribution Statement for the relevant article type, signed by all authors
- The ethics committee/IRB approval letter, or the client’s consent for case reports
- The relevant reporting checklist (e.g., CONSORT, PRISMA, CARE)
- A separate title page and a fully anonymized manuscript, as required for double-blind review
Manuscripts not submitted in accordance with the AJCBT Instructions for Authors are returned to the authors for correction before further processing.
After this administrative screening, manuscripts are triaged by the Editor, the Managing Editor, or a designated Editorial Board member, who evaluates originality, significance, methodological rigor, and suitability with respect to the journal’s scope and standards. At this stage, a manuscript may be rejected if it is unsuitable for the journal, lacks scientific rigor, falls outside the journal’s scope, or fails to meet submission requirements.
All manuscripts are screened for textual similarity using plagiarism-detection software (e.g., Turnitin) before entering peer review. In line with the Higher Education Commission (HEC) of Pakistan’s Plagiarism Policy, the overall similarity index must be below 19%. Manuscripts exceeding this limit are returned to authors for clarification or revision, and are rejected if plagiarism, redundant publication, or text recycling is confirmed.
Manuscripts may be returned to authors for revision or correction identified during editorial screening. Once the revisions are satisfactory, the manuscript proceeds to external peer review. For details of the peer review stage and final decision-making, see the AJCBT Peer Review Policy (Journal Policy 5).
