Journal Policy 11: Crossmark Policy: Errata, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern

Journal Policy 11

The editorial team of the Asian Journal of Cognitive Behavior Therapy (AJCBT) upholds the highest standards of research integrity, and is committed to maintaining the accuracy of all published content and to notifying readers promptly of any necessary corrections. AJCBT welcomes responsible correspondence, including Letters to the Editor that offer constructive or alternative perspectives on published material.

Corrections are issued for verified errors. If any error, misconduct, or ethical concern is reported after publication, the Editor will convene a Publication and Research Integrity Committee of impartial experts to conduct a thorough and fair investigation. Based on its findings, appropriate action — such as a correction, expression of concern, or retraction — will be taken.

Erratum

An erratum is a correction of an error introduced by the journal during editing or production, including failure to incorporate proof corrections requested by the authors within the designated time.

At the proof stage, AJCBT provides the corresponding author with the final version of the article for review and approval before publication.

Errata are not issued for minor typographical errors that do not affect meaning; however, an erratum is published when an apparently simple error is significant (e.g., an incorrect value in a table, or an incorrect corresponding author email). Where a major error occurs in a figure or table, a corrected version is published as an erratum, at the Editor’s discretion.

Corrigendum

A corrigendum is a change to an article that the authors wish to publish after acceptance. Corrigenda are published if the scientific accuracy or reproducibility of the original paper is affected, or if there is an error in the author list, but not usually for overlooked acknowledgements. Authors should contact the Editor, who will decide on the appropriate course of action.

Readers wishing to draw attention to a significant error should submit a Letter to the Editor. Such letters are reviewed by independent referees and, if accepted, sent to the original authors for an opportunity to respond.

Addenda

Addenda are judged on the significance of the addition to the interpretation of the original publication. If authors inadvertently omitted significant information that was available to them at the time, it may be published as an addendum after peer review.

Expressions of Concern

AJCBT may issue an Expression of Concern (EOC) when the editors have credible reasons to believe that an article may contain misleading or unreliable information, but conclusive evidence is not yet available. An EOC may be published when:

  • The editors receive inconclusive evidence of possible research or publication misconduct.
  • There is evidence of unreliable findings, but the authors’ institution declines or fails to investigate.
  • The editors have reasonable doubts about the fairness or conclusiveness of an institutional investigation.
  • An investigation is ongoing but is expected to take a considerable time.

The EOC serves as an interim notice to readers until the matter is resolved and a final decision — correction, retraction, or dismissal — is made.

Retractions

Articles with serious errors that invalidate their results and conclusions, or involving publication misconduct, may be retracted. Retractions may be requested by the authors, an institution, readers, or the Editor. In line with COPE retraction guidelines, AJCBT will consider retraction if:

  • There is clear evidence that the findings are unreliable, due to major error or to fabrication or falsification of data
  • It constitutes plagiarism
  • The findings have been published elsewhere without proper attribution, disclosure, or permission (redundant publication)
  • It contains material or data used without authorization
  • Copyright has been infringed, or there is another serious legal issue
  • It reports unethical research, including research without appropriate ethics approval or participant consent
  • It was published on the basis of a compromised or manipulated peer review process
  • The authors failed to disclose a major conflict of interest that, in the Editor’s view, would have unduly affected the interpretation of the work
  • An article may occasionally be retracted for correction of errors and replaced with a corrected version

Retraction Process

  • An article requiring potential retraction is brought to the attention of the Editor.
  • The Editor follows the COPE flowcharts step by step and seeks a response from the authors.
  • The Publication and Research Integrity Committee evaluates the evidence and the authors’ response, and recommends a final decision.
  • The decision is communicated to the authors and, where necessary, to other relevant bodies such as the authors’ institution.
  • A retraction note titled “Retraction: [article title]” is published in a subsequent issue and listed in its contents, explaining why the article is retracted.
  • The retraction notice and the original article are clearly linked online, so that the retraction is apparent to anyone who finds the original article. The original article is retained but clearly marked as retracted.
  • Relevant changes will be reflected through the CrossMark icon, once in place.

CrossMark

CrossMark is a multi-publisher initiative from Crossref that provides a standard way for readers to find the current version of a piece of content. Once AJCBT is registered with Crossref and assigning DOIs, the journal will apply the CrossMark logo, committing to maintain the content it publishes and to alert readers to changes when they occur.

CrossMark status will remain current for:

  • Minor changes (such as correcting formatting and spelling) with no substantive change to alert the reader
  • Changes that do not affect the crediting or interpretation of the work
  • CrossMark status will be updated in case of major changes, such as:
  • The retraction of an article
  • Changes between versions that reflect major changes in the content of the paper
  • A correction to an author’s name

The CrossMark icon will apply to current and future journal content once registration with Crossref is complete.