Journal Policy 5
The Asian Journal of Cognitive Behavior Therapy (AJCBT) is a peer-reviewed journal following a DOUBLE-BLIND PEER REVIEW system: the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the process. AJCBT aims to build a panel of peer reviewers with diversity in knowledge, viewpoint, and expertise across CBT, clinical psychology, psychiatry, and allied mental health fields.
Selection of Reviewers
Reviewers are selected based on their subject expertise, demonstrated through relevant academic qualifications, clinical experience, and/or a record of publications in the field. Preference is given to reviewers with recent research or clinical activity related to the manuscript’s topic. Reviewers must have no conflicts of interest with the authors, institutions, or funding sources. The journal aims to maintain a diverse and up-to-date reviewer database to ensure quality and impartial peer review.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers are required to assess the manuscript using the reviewer’s form provided, or to provide a detailed narrative review. The evaluation should include:
- The originality and importance of the research, and its relevance to CBT practice or research
- The design of the study
- The methods, including analytical and statistical approaches (a statistical review may be initiated by the editors if recommended by reviewers or deemed necessary)
- For intervention studies: the description of the intervention and any cultural adaptation, therapist training and supervision, and treatment fidelity
- The validity of outcome measures in the population and cultural context studied
- The presentation of results, including clinical as well as statistical significance
- The discussion of findings in the light of existing evidence, and possible confounders
- The strength of the conclusions
- The ethical conduct of the study, including consent and participant safety
- The overall quality of the manuscript
- Reviewers are required to recommend to the editor whether a manuscript is suitable for publication, with narrative comments supporting their recommendation (acceptance, revision, or rejection), and may be asked to evaluate aspects such as originality, quality, accuracy, readability, and reader interest.
- Reviewers should declare to the editor any potential conflicts of interest with respect to the authors or content of a manuscript, and in most instances should decline to review when such conflicts exist.
- Reviewers must treat the manuscript as a confidential document and must not show it to anyone else without the editor’s express consent.
- Reviewers should not make derogatory comments about a manuscript; the editor may edit or withhold such comments from the authors.
- Reviewers must not attempt to identify the authors, disclose their own identity, or communicate directly with the authors at any stage of the review process.
- Reviewers should meet the agreed deadline (usually 4 weeks) for manuscript review and respond to reminders.
Identification and Evaluation of Reviewers
- The editor will maintain a reviewer database including each reviewer’s expertise and contact information.
- Potential reviewers may be identified through knowledge of the field, PACT and other professional networks, the Editorial and Advisory Boards, database searches (e.g., PsycINFO, PubMed, Google Scholar), or referrals from reviewers who decline an invitation.
- Only reviewers who consent to be on the review panel will be added to the AJCBT online review system.
- Authors may suggest potential reviewers; the editor may consider these suggestions but is under no obligation to use them. Authors may also request that certain individuals not be invited to review their manuscript, and the editor will consider such requests case by case.
- Review requests will be sent to potential reviewers through the online journal system, with the documents required for assessment.
- The editor is responsible for tracking reviewers and ensuring reviews are completed in a timely manner. Reviews may be rated and stored with the reviewer’s profile. Reviewers who consistently decline invitations or submit brief, unhelpful reviews may be removed from the database.
- To avoid overworking reviewers, each reviewer will typically be asked to evaluate no more than one manuscript per month. Reviewers have the right to decline a review for any reason.
Note: Due to the blind peer review policy, review details are not shared publicly; however, they may be shared with international indexing agencies and the Higher Education Commission (HEC) Pakistan on demand or during journal evaluation.
Use of AI Tools by Reviewers
- Reviewers must never upload any part of a manuscript to AI tools (e.g., ChatGPT, Gemini, Copilot) or other platforms that store, reuse, or share content.
- AI tools may be used only for language polishing of the reviewer’s own written comments, and must never be used to generate review content, interpret data, or analyze the manuscript.
- Reviewers remain solely responsible for the accuracy, integrity, and confidentiality of their review. See also the AJCBT AI Policy (Journal Policy 12).
Rewarding Reviewers
- A thank-you email will be sent to each reviewer on completion of their review through the online review system.
- A review certificate, signed by the Editor, may be sent by email to the reviewer on request.
- Reviewers may claim credit for their reviews through a recognized reviewer-recognition platform (e.g., ORCID).
Decision Making and Communication to Authors
- The Editor makes the final decision on a manuscript (acceptance, revision, or rejection) after considering reviewers’ comments, the handling editor’s assessment, and other relevant factors.
- Factors influencing the decision include reviewer comments and recommendations, space availability, and — most importantly — the Editor’s judgment of the manuscript’s quality, value, and relevance to the journal’s readership.
- The Editor may seek additional review and advice, if required.
- The final decision will be communicated to authors, with explanation where necessary.
- Rejection may be based on scientific weaknesses (e.g., poor design, inappropriate methodology), lack of originality, or limited relevance to readers. The reasons will be clearly explained, especially where the decision contrasts with generally favorable reviewer comments.
- If reviewer comments are contradictory, the editor will determine which recommendations authors should follow and communicate this clearly.
Editorial Decision Appeals
Authors have the right to appeal editorial decisions, including rejection, if they believe the decision was based on an error in the review process or a misunderstanding of the work. Appeals must be submitted in writing to the Editor within 30 days of receiving the decision letter, clearly stating the reasons for contesting the decision, with supporting evidence or clarifications.
The appeal will be reviewed by the Editor in consultation with at least one senior Editorial Board member not involved in the original decision; the Chief Advisor may also be consulted. An additional independent reviewer may be invited if necessary. The decision on the appeal will be communicated within 6–8 weeks. Decisions made after the appeal process are final.
Submissions from PACT, the Editor, and Editorial Team Members
- Manuscripts submitted by PACT office-bearers or by members of the editorial team will be assigned to an Editorial Board member with no conflict of interest (not from the same institution or research group as the submitting author).
- Where the Editor is an author, the manuscript will be handled entirely by a designated Editorial Board member, and the Editor will take no part in its review or in the decision.
- Such manuscripts undergo the same double-blind peer review as all other submissions, by at least two independent reviewers from outside the authors’ institutions and PACT.
- The editorial decision will be based solely on the quality, originality, and relevance of the work.
